LawDebenture

When I engage with sponsors about pension scheme buyout projects – by which I mean the end-to-end process of buy-in, buyout and wind-up of a pension scheme - I am mindful to explain the steps involved, whilst trying to set clear expectations for the realistic length of time the whole process is likely to take. All parties need to approach a transaction with a clear understanding of the volume of work and time commitment involved, an understanding of the impact/implications of the transaction and an expectation of the likely costs, so that there are no surprises. If there isn’t full transparency at the outset and throughout the process, there is scope for misunderstandings and frustrations. Trustees play a pivotal role in a pension scheme buyout project, ensuring the project remains on track and is delivered within agreed timescales and budgets. These are some of the key stages where trustee engagement is critical:

  • When a decision has been made to pursue a buyout, sponsors reasonably expect to see the project progressed in a timely manner, especially against the backdrop of favourable buyout market pricing and the desire to transact before ‘missing the boat’. But approaching the buyout market before a scheme is ‘buyout ready’ will not necessarily lead to the best pricing or the best engagement from insurers. A careful judgement needs to be made, weighing up the benefits of the potentially greater market engagement and keener pricing that might be secured from a ‘buyout ready’ scheme, against the benefits of an opportunistic market approach to secure transitory favourable pricing if the risks are considered acceptable. The work involved to get a scheme ‘buyout ready’ generally involves data gap analysis to identify gaps such as missing addresses and calculating contingent spouse pension amounts, preparing a benefit specification and agreeing with the sponsor how any discretions under the trust deed and rules should be codified. Preparation of benefit specifications and comparison with actual administration practice can often highlight benefit issues that need to be considered, resolved and rectified. Alongside this, schemes that were historically contracted-out may also be aiming to complete GMPE before approaching the buyout market. To maintain momentum and ensure buyout preparation is carried out as quickly and cost effectively as possible requires ongoing trustee engagement with advisers and availability for real-time decision making. This process can take several months for a typical scheme, depending on the number of issues that need to be addressed.
  • Once ‘buyout ready’ the pension scheme’s risk broking adviser will approach the buyout market and seek quotations. Depending on the size of scheme and the circumstances, this might be a whole of market exercise with a range of quotations being received, or a quotation from a single insurer on an exclusive basis. Once quotations have been received and checked, there is then often a very tight window to select the preferred provider, adjust assets to be in line with the price lock mechanism and negotiate contract terms. This tends to be an intense period of a few weeks where trustees need to be on standby for regular calls with advisers and quick decision making, alongside regular liaison with the sponsor on key decisions.
  • Once a buy-in has been transacted and the initial premium paid over to the insurer there is generally relief and celebration on a successful outcome after an intense period of work. This can also be a time for loss of engagement from all parties, now the deal is done. Yet, I would argue that this is the start of the period where trustees need to closely monitor progress and liaise regularly with the insurer and advisers to ensure momentum is retained and the true-up period does not drag on any longer than is necessary. I am acutely aware that insurers have had capacity issues in recent years due to the sheer volume of buyout transactions taking place in the market and this has often elongated timescales for true-up periods. But trustees can work with insurers and advisers to understand the insurer timescales, explore how these might be reduced and ensure that information is delivered to the insurer in a timely manner so the scheme does not lose its place in the queue. The longer the true-up phase takes, the more the BAU costs of running the scheme mount up; the more likely the trustees will be to hit statutory triennial valuation deadlines, accounting deadlines and other such milestones requiring advisers to divert focus away from completing the buyout and incur further costs. This can also be a period where sponsors can get frustrated at any delays in the process and so it is vital to keep the sponsor updated and to be proactive to drive this last stage of the project forward. Then, finally, when the buyout is in sight, trustees need to engage in project planning the final stages of buyout and wind-up with their advisers to ensure that these final tasks are completed as efficiently as possible.

The above illustrates that there is significant work and time commitment required from trustees in order to achieve a pension scheme buyout. Close ongoing involvement is needed over an extended period, with some ‘pinch points’ where constant availability for executive decision making is required, for example, during contract negotiations. A buyout project is therefore not something that can be accommodated purely within a quarterly trustee meeting cycle. More frequent meetings, decision making and action will be required. Therefore, when engaging with sponsors at the start of a buyout project, an important consideration will be the current trustee model and whether the current trustees will be able to adapt to meet these requirements. Where, due to other constraints, it would be challenging for the current trustee model to meet this level of commitment, or where the existing board has little/no experience of such projects, one option schemes consider is to transition to a Professional Corporate Sole Trustee (PCST) model.

Law Debenture has significant experience of transitioning to and operating under a PCST model. Under a PCST, a pension scheme is governed by a dedicated team of trustee directors and governance professionals capable of executive decision making, with the flexibility to be able to draw in additional resource and expertise from within the wider team as required. Law Debenture also has extensive, end-to-end experience of buy-ins, buyouts and wind-ups, having transacted 50 buy-ins, with one third of these having also completed the entire journey to the end of wind-up and the remaining schemes currently progressing towards this end. Our Trustees ensure they keep their knowledge up to date on innovations in the market and have experience, collectively, of working with a large number of providers. We are familiar with the providers’ processes, as well as having relationships with senior contacts, providing a route for escalation, should a project hit any bumps in the road. Drawing on our experience, we are also able to anticipate potential issues before they arise and proactively seek solutions to avoid delays. Combining our engame experience under a PCST model has enabled Law Debenture to deliver buyout projects in a very focused and efficient manner.

One recent example, was a small scheme with £20m of assets and liabilities where Law Debenture was appointed as a PCST. The scheme initially had a funding deficit and alongside implementing a revised investment strategy, de-risking to ‘lock in’ funding gains, we insured the necessary buyout preparatory work was completed. Therefore, as soon as the scheme’s funding gap had closed, the risk brokers were able to approach the insurance market in a timely manner and secure a buy-in on favourable terms. By remaining focused, and through agile decision making facilitated by our PCST model, we were able to complete the true-up, including a complex residual benefit rectification, and then buyout and wind-up the scheme.

If you would like to find out more about Law Debenture’s PCST model and how we can help your scheme please contact Scott Pinder: scott.pinder@lawdeb.com.

The latest from LawDeb